Our Attorneys & Staff

Tony Eufinger is a third generation attorney carrying on his family’s legacy of serving our community for nearly a century. Paul Mills has over 30 years of experience as an attorney and an area pastor. Get to know us and you’ll understand why we say your family is our priority.

Tony Eufinger | Founder & Owner

Tony Eufinger is an attorney at law and the founder and owner of Eufinger Law Offices, LLC. He graduated with honors from Capital University Law School with a Juris Doctorate in 2009 and from Ohio University with a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism in 1999.

Tony focuses his practice on estate planning for families and individuals. This includes drafting wills, trusts and powers of attorney as well as preparing strategies for avoiding probate and maximizing the benefits of individual estate plans. Tony concentrates on other probate matters including will and trust contests, estate and trust administration, and establishing and maintaining guardianships.

In addition to the estate planning practice, the attorneys of Eufinger Law Offices, LLC represent numerous personal injury clients in such matters as automobile accidents, premises liability, and wrongful death claims. They perform work in real estate matters including contract negotiations, foreclosure defense, landlord tenant law, and title work and real estate closings. Tony is a licensed title agent and the President and CEO of the Heart of Ohio Title Company. Tony serves as the village solicitor for Milford Center, and is a former Assistant Marysville City Prosecutor.

Tony is the third generation of his family to practice law in Union County, following his late grandfather William L. Coleman, a former Union County Prosecuting Attorney; his parents the Honorable Judge Charlotte Coleman Eufinger of the Union County Probate and Juvenile Court and John M. Eufinger, a retired magistrate in the Delaware County Juvenile Court; and his uncle Stephen G. Coleman. For the last ten years, Eufinger Law Offices, LLC has received the Marysville Journal Tribune’s Readers’ Choice Award as the favorite law firm in Union County.

Prior to practicing law, Tony worked overseas in London, England for ABC News as an assignment editor, assistant producer and abcnews.com writer where he received a Peabody Award for his contributions to ABC News’ coverage of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. He has previously worked in public and community relations, including two years for the Marysville School District where he helped administer a digital charter school.

Tony and his wife Megan Mattison Eufinger live in Marysville with their daughter Kate. They are active volunteers with the United Way of Union County and with the Beloved United Methodist Church in Marysville.

Paul Mills | Attorney

Paul Mills graduated from the University of Dayton School of Law in 1989 and was admitted the bar the same year. He practiced for several years in Dayton, Ohio. His emphasis was personal injury, workers compensation, and social security disability. He also has extensive litigation experience. He is authorized to practice in the Federal District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals for the United States, and the United States Supreme Court. Paul focuses on estate planning, probate and trust administration, and real estate matters.

Paul is also an ordained minister. He moved to Marysville in 2014 to pastor a local church. Paul, and his wife, Terri, have 3 adult sons – Wyatt, Dylan and Spencer; 3 daughters-in-law – Cilla, Dana, and Leanne; and 2 grandsons – Athey and Liam. Terri is a Certified Public Accountant and serves as a controller for a manufacturing company with offices in Dublin. Family is a priority to Paul and Terri. “I decided to join the staff at Eufinger Law Offices, because our firm is not simply driven by a bottom-line approach. Our desire is to compassionately serve the families of Union County. It is my great privilege to become a part of this long-standing tradition of service.”

Megan Mattison Eufinger | Chief Operating Officer

Originally from Coshocton, Ohio; Megan joined Eufinger Law Offices, officially, in 2012 and brings extensive experience in association executive management, event planning, sales and marketing. She manages the day-to-day operations for both the law firm and the Heart of Ohio Title Company, helping to ensure our clients receive a positive and meaningful legal experience. Megan is a graduate of Bowling Green State University with a Bachelor of Arts in Communications, Marketing and Public Relations and is also a Certified Association Executive.

In her free time, she enjoys reading, traveling internationally, annoyingly difficult sudoku puzzles and volunteering in the Marysville community. Megan, her husband Tony and daughter Kate live in Marysville with their two corgis Hazel and Archie, basset hound Winston and Kate’s beloved orange cat, Lenny.

Megan and Tony have always believed in the importance of family, friends and community. “When Tony first shared his dream of opening a private practice in his home town, I was beyond excited. His commitment to his family and love for Union County have allowed him to continue the Coleman & Eufinger legacy of compassionate and positive legal services.”

Meet Our Team

Denise Nahvi, MBA

Legal Data Strategist

  • Denise joined Eufinger Law Offices in 2024, bringing with her an expansive background in business, marketing and dedication to family and community.

    She holds a Bachelor of Science in Marketing and a Master of Business Administration. Prior to joining the firm, Denise focused on raising her three children, a role that strengthened her organizational and multitasking skills.

    Residing in Marysville with her husband, Justin, and their 3 children, Denise enjoys being an active supporter of her family, cheering on her kids in all their activities.

    Her blend of professional expertise and personal dedication makes her an invaluable part of the Eufinger team.

Cande Brake

Paralegal

  • Originally from Mingo, Ohio; Cande has worked with Eufinger Law Offices and the Eufinger Family for over 35 years. She brings a wealth of knowledge to our practice, particularly in the areas of Probate Estates and Real Estate Documents.

    Cande is a graduate of Triad High School and Ohio Hi-Point JVS. Throughout her years in our community, she served as the Fiscal Officer of Allen Township for 18 years and taught at the Methodist Creative Preschool.

    Cande resides in Marysville with her husband, Doug. She enjoys gardening, scrapbooking, reading and spending time with her family.

Paula Dappert

Director of First Impressions

  • Paula joined Eufinger Law Offices in 2025. Earning her Real Estate License in 2005 and working in the industry for over two decades, she has extensive experience in Real Estate transactions and client relations. In addition to assisting with title company tasks, Paula also supports our attorneys in all practice areas including estate planning and probate estates.

    Paula and her husband Greg reside in Logan County. They have two daughters and six grandchildren.

    Outside of the office, She enjoys quality time with her grandchildren and family. Paula also has a passion for home improvement including decorating, architecture, gardening and landscaping.

Assistant Manager, Heart of Ohio Title Company

Sara Thirkield

  • Originally from Cleveland, Ohio; Sara joined the Heart of Ohio Title Company in 2025. A graduate from Case Western University, she holds a Bachelors Degree in Sociology and Communication Sciences and Disorders.

    Sara brings a strong background in accounting and customer service to Heart of Ohio Title and offers a unique perspective having previously worked education as a Special Education teacher and behavior therapist.

    Sara resides locally with her husband Kyle, their children and corgi Sarge. She enjoys spending time with her family, cooking all things outdoors and football season! Sara also has a particular passion for exploring our local community and supporting the small businesses within it.

Allie Baber

Probate Paralegal

  • A native of North Carolina, Allie attended the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and holds Bachelors Degrees in both Spanish and International Business.

    Allie joined Eufinger Law Offices in 2025 and is quickly becoming our resident Probate Expert. In addition to being fluent in Spanish, she brings a wealth of expertise from her experience in customer service, having worked in multiple client-facing settings.

    Allie holds the prestigious Girl Scouts of the USA Gold Award. A project that sparked a life-long passion for community service, by allowing her to give back to her local community of Franklinville, NC.

    Currently, Allie resides locally with her husband, Alex; and they now call Ohio home. She enjoys traveling (especially internationally), baking, spending time exploring the outdoors and shopping.

How can we help? Contact us today.

Fill out the form below or call us at 937-642-1819.